Total
Cleaning efficiency
Protection

Good absorbing swab, lacks protection on the weight.

The tissue used on the swab is nice and soft, gets the job done and dries out quite rapidly when left out in the open. The only downside I've found is that the metallic weight is not protected. It will rub on your sax's neck and might damage the lacquer.

Not at all a bad bet but if you buy this item get a bit of heat shrink tubing and make a rubber bumper over the weight.